• Postcall
  • Posts
  • AI medical chatbots flunk the test 🤦🏽‍♀️

AI medical chatbots flunk the test 🤦🏽‍♀️

PLUS: a Pikachu card wanders, 🧧 prevent money squanders, and brain fog ponders

It’s the week of Halloween! — and what’s in store?

A gentle tapping — as if someone’s rapping…

Rapping on your email door. 😱

Do you feel a chill? Is that… a whisper? 🌬️

Could it be Postcall — your weekly news sifter —

Bringing you medicine, spice, and games galore? 🫨

Quoth the Dog-tor… “Forevermore!” 🐦‍⬛

🎃 Have a happy 😄, hair-raising 🙀, howling 🐺, haunted 👻 Halloween! 🎃 

Now on to our headlines!

  • What patients might say this week 🙊 

    "Why limit drinking when life keeps pouring shots of absurdity?”

  • 🏀 Baller of the Month: Dr. Yatin Chadha

    He’s a radiologist, podcaster, & financial literacy advocate for doctors.

  • We’ve partnered with a conference you may not want to miss

    Get the Postcallers’ discount to attend the CPFW Conference.

  • Pikachu and Taylor Swift are both things we can’t get enough of 🎙️ 

    But you can only get one of them.

  • AI medical chatbots flunk the test 🤦🏽‍♀️

    New research is diagnosing racial bias in virtual medics.

  • Play: this week’s Postcall med-themed crossword puzzle ! ⛳️

    See if your brain can keep up with your confidence 😜

Driving these numbers: Bitcoin jumped on expectations of a Bitcoin ETF approval, but markets are in waiting mode. There are two events happening this week:

  1. The beginning of tech earnings season (Microsoft crushed their Q3 projections on strong revenue from cloud yesterday).

  2. The Bank of Canada’s rate decision this morning (expected to stay flat because of slowing inflation).

What patients might say this week 🙊 

  1. “Is this gonna hurt?”

A new study published in the British Medical Journal found that out of 24 high-income countries, Canada ranks highest in injury during childbirth from forceps- and vacuum-assisted deliveries. The rate of maternal trauma is 16% in Canadian mothers, compared to 5% for other countries.

Correlation among operative vaginal deliveries (Pearson’s correlation coefficient=0.76; P=0.01)

  1. “One tequila, two tequila, three tequila, floor!”

Canada has new guidelines on recognizing and treating moderate to high-risk drinking. Among the 15 new recommendations, use of naltrexone or acamprosate is recommended as first-line for supporting abstinence or reduction in moderate to severe alcohol use disorder. Of note, naltrexone is contraindicated with concomitant treatment for chronic opioid therapy and in acute hepatitis.

  1. “Why does long Covid cause brain fog?”

A study published in Cell last week has shown that molecules called viral RNA-induced type 1 interferons, released by the Covid virus, deplete the body of serotonin. This serotonin slump can impair cognition, resulting in the brain fog and memory problems often cited as sequelae of long Covid.

  1. “Are OACs for Afib contraindicated in brain bleeds?”

It’s a tricky one, but according to a letter published in the Lancet, authors from the (still ongoing) ENRICH-AF trial recommend that patients with two particular types of intracranial hemorrhage (lobar intracranial and convexity subarachnoid) stop receiving edoxaban due to an unacceptably high risk of recurrent hemorrhagic stroke. But don’t worry, there’s at least five ongoing trials still studying this very topic, so don’t change your practice just yet!

Presented by The Canadian Physicians Financial Wellness Conference

Ask for advice, get money twice 💰️💰️ 

To continue with the wisdom of Pitbull — plus all the physicians that came before: what you learned in med school is only a fraction of what you need for a successful career in medicine.

So what can we do about it? The Canadian Physicians Financial Wellness Conference is back, and it's bigger and better than ever. And we have an exclusive deal below for our Postcall readers to level up.

The CPFW conference is bringing you the 2023 lineup on 5 core topics, all in an easy afternoon:

  • Job Contract Negotiation: Ever wondered about the intricacies of your employment contract? Join Doctor/Employment Lawyer Dr. Adam Shehata and ER Doctor Katie Lin as they spill the beans on contract negotiations.

  • Financial Mistakes to Avoid: Dr. Yatin Chadha shares his wisdom on financial pitfalls to steer clear of, especially as a fresh-faced medical graduate.

  • Does Money Buy Happiness?: They’ve seen it all as founders of the PFI FB group, Drs. Jane & Paul Healey. BONUS, For Mainpro+ you can claim a Non-Certified credit and Self-Learning CME credits.

  • Beat the Bank with ETF Investing: Larry Bates, the author of "Beat the Bank," will guide you through the world of investments and how to make your money work for you.

  • Retirement Planning & Pensions: Dr. Mark Soth will help you navigate the maze of retirement planning, ensuring a secure future.

  • Money Saving Tips for CaRMS: Dr. Adri-Anna Aloia & Dr. Eric Poon tells all about how they saved while ensuring they match to their specialty of choice.

Early bird tickets are available until Oct. 31st…

BUT…

Readers who use the code “postcall” or click this link will get an exclusive 10% discount on tickets.

Frequently Asked Questions:

  • Do the organizers have any conflict of interest? Nope, the ticket proceeds go towards charitable causes.

  • Will the conference be recorded? Yes, ticket holders have access to the recordings for 1 year.

🏀 Baller of the Month 🏀 

Who is Dr. Yatin Chadha?

He’s a diagnostic radiologist who’s trained and worked across the US and Canada, and he’s the head of MSK Imaging at North York General. But that’s not even the most interesting thing about him.

In his free time, he runs beyond MD, a popular podcast where he features leading people and resources that help Canadian doctors with their financial literacy. In his conversation with Postcall, he shared two nuggets…

Nugget #1: “What are the critical topics for physicians to know about financial literacy?”

For those starting out, he stressed the importance of grasping:

  1. Incorporation: when to incorporate, salaries vs. dividends, and even how to use corporate funds without drowning in taxes.

  2. Insurance (including disability, life, and critical illness policies).

  3. Financials around home buying and mortgages.

  4. Common sense investing to make your money work hard, so you don't have to.

As physicians progress into the mid-career phase, Dr. Chadha recommended focusing on:

  1. Tax efficiency as corporations grow; understanding the capital dividend account and optimizing income splitting.

  2. How to optimize travelling a bit more (ie. credit cards, optimizing travel rewards).

  3. Giving back, and tax efficient philanthropy.

If you’re considering doing something similar to Dr. Yatin Chadha, he gave us Nugget #2: “Who should or shouldn’t get into content creation?”

“I found when things slowed down in 2020, there was one month where our imaging volumes just plummeted. That's when I came up with the idea for the podcast! Three big reasons I love it:

  1. Content creation can be a great thing because you're learning about the subject matter. I've done a lot of radiology: residency, fellowship, etc., but the learning doesn't stop when you graduate.

  2. Content creation is for people who want to continuously network, meet new people, both inside medicine and outside of medicine. I’ve been able to land a few guests on my podcast that have just blown my mind.

  3. Creativity. I truly do enjoy churning through cases day to day, but the novelty fades. Continuously building new interests in life would be the other reason for somebody to pursue content creation, regardless of whether or not it flourishes into a new business.”

What about any downsides or risks?

  1. “I can tell you in the early days, some people were wondering, ‘Why are you doing it? You're a physician, you should be focusing on medicine.’ But then, as it grew, I was able to explain to people why it's really important for me to continue to grow and develop.”

  2. “One risk is definitely if I was like, ‘I'm on here to advise people.’ I’m more in the space to educate people and just share knowledge. So I try to push that aside by putting in disclaimers and just emphasizing we're here to educate and learn together.”

Ready to level up your financial literacy? Dive into the world of financial literacy for physicians with Dr. Yatin Chadha's podcast, beyond MD! (Apple | Spotify)

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

🍔 Quick Bites

1: 📣 There's growing opposition to making family doctor training longer (which the CFPC is moving towards ahead of its AGM in November). The College says, “Two years is not enough time to learn the core skills,” while med students say, "If this third year were to happen, they would not become family doctors." Meanwhile, provincial health ministers are firmly opposed to the extension due to the shortage of FM docs. 👇 What do you think? 👇

Should family medicine residency remain 2 years?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

2: 💰️ Wondering why big business keeps raising prices? The Competition Bureau of Canada may have found the cause: our economy’s competitive intensity has fallen over the last 20 years. In response, the federal government is pushing to change legislation so regulators can have an easier time preventing consolidation and introducing more entrants in key industries, like groceries, telecoms, and air travel.

3: 🐕 Bobi, the world’s oldest dog and certified Good Boi, passed away last Saturday at the age of 31 (nearly 31 ½). A purebred Rafeiro do Alentejo living in Portugal, he beat a nearly century-old record as the oldest dog ever. The secret to his longevity? 1: Genetics (his mother lived to age 18). 2: Living in a "calm, peaceful environment.” 🥹

AI medical chatbots flunk the test 🤦🏽‍♀️

Flunking a test isn’t the end of the world… Unless you’re a Resident Evil scientist battling zombies 🤔. But in the real world, flunking medical chatbots have — in the words of Dr. Roxana Daneshjou — “real world consequences.”

What happened: A recent study from Stanford School of Medicine delivered a reality-check on AI medical chatbots. ChatGPT, the newer GPT-4 (a.k.a. the annoying, know-it-all sibling), Google’s Bard, and Anthropic’s Claude have been caught spreading racially-biased and inaccurate medical information, potentially worsening health disparities for Black patients. When researchers quizzed chatbots about kidney function, lung capacity, and skin thickness, bots responded with racial misbeliefs 😬. No excuses here — postdoc researcher and study co-leader Tofuni Omiye grilled these chatbots on an encrypted laptop, resetting after each question to prevent bias.

Why it’s interesting: Medical experts have spent years combatting misconceptions about biological differences between Black and white individuals. Daneshjou finds it deeply concerning to see them regurgitated, as more physicians use chatbots for daily tasks. These misconceptions have led to misdiagnoses, the undervaluing of pain, and less effective treatments for Black patients. In Canada and the US, Black people face higher rates of chronic ailments, and COVID-19 due to race-related stress and medical bias.

Dr. Adam Rodman believes “no one in their right mind” would rely on a chatbot to calculate kidney function. But algorithms — which, like chatbots, draw on AI models for prediction — have been deployed in hospital settings for years, and many fail people of colour. In 2019, academic researchers uncovered hospitals using an algorithm that systematically favoured white patients, while Black patients had to be deemed much sicker to receive equal treatment.

Bottom line: Omiye is grateful his team discovered these racial biases early. He believes technology can provide shared prosperity and close gaps in healthcare delivery. Doctors are noticing more patients self-diagnosing with chatbots before appointments, and the medical chatbot market is predicted to hit $1.2 billion by 2032 (from $296 million in 2022). With Canada and the US facing a critical shortage of healthcare workers, these chatbots could become the first contact point for primary care — provided they stop ditching class and ace those tests on racial bias 📚.

Postcall Picks ✅ 

Pokemon at the Van Gogh museum in Amsterdam. Image: Photo by Remko de Waal / ANP / AFP) / via Getty.

🏠️ Live: In a brand new home, with a mortgage from Helen at BMO. Helen’s got physicians and residents covered for purchasing or refinancing, Canada-wide. And if you message her before Oct. 31, you’ll also get up to $4,000 cashback. 🎃 Call/Whatsapp 778-885-7618, or email [email protected]om to get your rate*

💳️ Buy: Pikachu with Grey Felt Hat promo card. Oh wait, because of the "unsafe swarming" by collectors and fans, the Van Gogh museum has removed it from the shelves. But some cards have been spotted on ecommerce websites for as much as €8,060. Ϟ(๑⚈ ․̫ ⚈๑)⋆

🎃 Eat: Only 6 more days in Oct, but the pumpkin fun doesn't need to stop there. Here is the ever delicious Pumpkin Pie Coffee Cake recipe.

👀 Watch: Taylor Swift Eras Tour concert movie, which held its top position against Scorcese this weekend by bringing in a whopping $31M.

* This is sponsored content

🕹️ Game ⛳️

IT’S TIME… 🤼 🤼‍♀️ … for our weekly challenging-but-super-fun crossword puzzle!

How will you compare to last week’s fastest time — 1:17?

First question: What is abnormal dryness of the eye’s conjunctiva and cornea?

If you enjoyed the puzzle, please share it! It’ll make our Puzzlemaker very happy. 🥰

Share Postcall, Get Exclusive Merch! 🐕

Share Postcall, rack up referrals, get merch. It’s that easy. Plus, you’ll get our eternal gratitude. Maybe we’ll name our next pet Shiba in your honour! 😜

Click here or share by copying and pasting this link: https://postcall.ca/subscribe?ref=PLACEHOLDER

It only takes a few referrals to start earning fun Postcall swag, starting with our sticker pack when you get 3 friends to sign up!

What'd you think of today's edition?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

🤘 If you’re reading this, you know that our readers are Canada's best and brightest physicians, medical learners, and other smart, ambitious people. Learn about partnering with Postcall.